Car enthusiast couple die trying to put classic Mercedes in storage bag

Couple succumbed to carbon monoxide poisoning after trying to store classic car themselves

Car enthusiast couple die trying to put classic Mercedes in storage bag
Photo: Bigstock

A couple who were classic car enthusiasts died from carbon monoxide poisoning after reversing a Mercedes Benz into a protective storage bag, an inquest heard.

William Reid, 67, and his partner Kathryn Workman, 70, were overcome by fumes in the garage near their home on October 22, 2017.

The two-day inquest in Cockermouth, Cumbria, heard Mr Reid had collected and restored classic cars for years and did not seek help when storing the vehicle.

He had recently acquired a Mercedes from the United States and opted to store the vehicle in a large storage bag to protect it during the winter months.

The retired lorry driver attempted to reverse it into the bag with the help of Mrs Workman while in their garage, which was located below road level at the bottom of a slope and attached to the house next door.

But Mr Reid was overcome by carbon monoxide fumes – which is odourless – and became unconscious, an inquest heard.

Ms Workman entered the bag to help her partner but was also affected by the fumes, although she managed to crawl back out and call emergency services.

Warned to stay away

She was initially told to keep away from the area by a call handler due to the risk of carbon monoxide intoxication.

While Mrs Workman was on the phone, confusion about what was happening in the garage led to the operator then advising her to get as near as possible to her partner and try to treat him.

She tried to wake Mr Reid but was unable to and shortly after stopped responding on the call, an inquest heard.

North West Ambulance Service paramedic Ben Sayner was first on the scene near the couple’s High Seaton home following a dispatch at around 12pm.

Mr Sayner explored the property but, due to the unusual location of the garage, it was not until his partner arrived that they discovered the unconscious couple.

He said: “We ripped the bag open and there was a very strong smell of fumes so we ran out.”

Paramedics opened as many doors as they could before going back into the garage to rescue Ms Workman, although Mr Reid was deemed to be too far into the bag to reach without breathing equipment.

Mrs Workman suffered a cardiac arrest and had to be taken by ambulance to hospital. She died two days later.

It was not until the Cumbria Fire and Rescue Service arrived that emergency services could get to Mr Reid, who was removed from the bag and treated but was pronounced dead at the scene at 1.13pm.

Post-mortems found Mr Reid had died from poisoning by carbon monoxide, while Mrs Workman died by hypoxic brain injury due to poisoning by carbon monoxide.

Storage bag a struggle to tear open

Detective Sergeant Martin Hodgson, who investigated the incident for Cumbria Police, said the bag was one you would “definitely struggle” to tear open.

Transcripts of the calls made between the emergency services and Ms Workman were read out and revealed the operator had advised Ms Workman to try to get as close to her partner as possible and lie him on his back.

A system error had led to the first attempt to alert the fire service being inadvertently cancelled.

However, an investigation carried out by the ambulance service found that the operator’s decision had been “accepted as reasonable”.

This was because it was felt they could not have known this would place Ms Workman in a hazardous environment due to the confusing language used to describe the situation.

Number of errors

The report said: “A number of errors were made during the initial 999 call.”

Coroner Simon Ward said Mrs Workman told the handler she was going back into the bag to help her partner of her own initiative.

He added: “I’m satisfied she would have still tried to help Mr Reid irrespective of the instructions of the call handler.

“Mrs Workman was aware she may become unconscious.

“My view is she would have still tried to help him and that’s a credit to her dedication to their relationship.

“Mrs Workman would have done all she could to help Mr Reid irrespective of her own safety.”

Mr Ward said it was unlikely either of them would have survived.

He concluded Mr Reid died as a result of an accident while recording a verdict of misadventure for Mrs Workman.

Is there enough awareness of the dangers of carbon monoxide poisoning? Should the couple have got professional help to store the car? Are storage bags dangerous? Let us know in the comments.

Have your say!

1 0

Lost Password

Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.