EV’s twice as likely to ‘breakdown’ with wheel or tyre damage than petrol or diesel cars

Third of breakdown call-outs to EV owners are down to punctures or wheel damage

EV’s twice as likely to ‘breakdown’ with wheel or tyre damage than petrol or diesel cars

Electric vehicles (EVs) are twice as likely to suffer from a wheel or tyre-related breakdown than their petrol or diesel equivalents according to a major recovery service, new research suggests.

Liverpool Victoria’s breakdown division, LV= Britannia Rescue, say that more than a third of call-outs to EV owners are down to punctures, wheel issues or tyre damage.

The number of drivers calling them out to deal with batteries running out of charge is much lower than most would expect, making up just 11 per cent of all EV calls.

That’s less than a third of the amount who need emergency assistance due to wheel and tyre issues at 36 per cent.

LV= Britannia Rescue, who compiled the information between 2018 and 2021, found that petrol and diesel owners needed help less than half as much as EV owners for the same problems at 16 per cent.

Motorway breakdowns: Majority of motorists would wait in dangerous place, survey finds

In a statement, the recovery firm said: “Wheel or tyre problems are often attributed to the excess weight of the car, caused by the battery, which can make it up to 50 percent heavier than a traditional petrol or diesel car.

“Wheel issues are sometimes made more complicated by the fact that most manufacturers no longer fit a spare wheel as standard, so drivers caught mid-journey with a flat tyre or wheel issue can’t fix the problem themselves and need towing to a local garage.”

Some tyre manufacturers are trying to mitigate the effects of the weight of EVs by making special tyres with rubber specifically designed for battery-powered cars.

EV tyres are made to be quieter than usual and with additional resistance in order to protect range and make them more energy efficient.

Related: Less than four per cent of EV breakdowns in 2020 were for “out of charge”

EV owners also suffer from the winter-tradition of a car not starting in the morning, with 21 per cent of call-outs to LV= Britannia Rescue due to what is known in the EV industry as ‘dead on key’ – it is twice as likely to happen to petrol or diesel owners at 41 per cent of call-outs, especially in the colder months.

Henry Topham, LV= Britannia Rescue’s Managing director said: “Generally electric cars perform very well and aren’t susceptible to suffering nearly as many issues as petrol or diesel models, but if you do have a problem it’s more likely to be wheel or tyre related, or dead on key.

“Range anxiety has been built up to be a thing for people to be concerned about when it comes to going green, but our data shows that in reality it’s a very rare issue for electric car drivers.”

2 Comments

  1. Rubbish, EV’s breakdown less so percentage of tyre/wheel related problems is always going to be higher ‘There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics’?

    Reply
  2. I also agree that the headline does not convey the truth but think that your reasoning is not entirely the reason. Currently the majority of EVs are significantly newer than the average vehicle age and comparted to ICE vehicles of similar age, may or may not be more reliable but the age is relevant. This fad with inflation kits in place of a spare wheel due to lazy design packaging and cost saving for the manufacturer means that almost no new vehicle has a spare wheel so perhaps the real reason is that as the average age of the EVs being significantly lower the percentage of them without a spare is greater. As you said, ‘lies, dam lies and statistics’ but quantification is the key!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Have your say!

0 0

Lost Password

Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.